Resistance or wisdom?

The art of trusting your limits.

After I sent yesterday’s email about my own hesitation to turn the shower to cold, a few people responded. One person shared they look forward to cold showers, and another said they’ve done them for so long that a shower feels incomplete without a cold burst at the end. Thank you for sharing—these responses made me feel part of something!

And then someone else wrote about a different kind of moment. They had a swim practice scheduled—something they usually love. But that day, something in them said no. So they skipped it. Not out of laziness or avoidance, but because something inside needed rest. And while there was a touch of FOMO, they were glad they listened.

That response has stayed with me. Because yes—sometimes what we label as resistance isn’t something to push through. Sometimes it’s wisdom.

But how do we tell the difference?

I recently finished reading Endure by Alex Hutchinson. He talks about the Central Governor Theory, first proposed by Dr. Timothy Noakes. It suggests our brains act like a kind of safety valve—like a governor on a car engine. It steps in, not because we’re out of fuel, but because it’s trying to protect us from burning out.

But, get this, the Perception Effect, proposed by Samuele Marcora is the idea that what we believe about our limits can shape how our body responds.

In other words, mindset isn’t just fluff. It’s the lens through which our brain interprets physical signals. If we expect something to feel hard, it probably will. If we trust we can stretch, our body often follows.

So now when that hesitation creeps in—whether I’m standing in front of a cold shower or debating whether to push through a workout—I pause and ask: Is this resistance… or protection? Is this my body calling for rest, or my brain playing it safe?

There’s no universal answer. But here are a few cues I listen for:

  • If I feel energized after skipping, it might’ve been the right kind of rest.
  • If I feel regretful or uneasy, maybe my Central Governor overreacted.
  • If I feel curious or slightly afraid, that’s often the edge where growth begins.

And here’s what I’ve come to realize: how we respond in those moments doesn’t just affect our own growth—it quietly shapes the space around us. Not because we’re trying to prove something or set an example, but because our presence becomes part of the emotional current – with our colleagues, our kids, and community.

The way we meet discomfort—whether with courage, pause, or curiosity—can invite others to do the same. It’s less about performance and more about resonance.

Tomorrow, I’ll share more about those ripples—what it means to stretch limits gently, for ourselves and in the spaces we hold.

But for now, I’d love to know:

When was the last time you overrode your hesitation… and were glad you did?

And when did honoring your hesitation feel like true self-trust?

Hit reply and share. These stories help shape the conversation.

Until tomorrow,
Shannon

P.S. Know someone who feels frustrated and stuck, wondering whether to push or pause? Forward this email. These are the quiet, brave conversations that help us all move with more trust.

One response to “Resistance or wisdom?”

  1. Diane McManus Avatar
    Diane McManus

    Interesting question about limits! Thanks for the post!
    I was just doing some open water swimming with my group yesterday, water temp 64. Overall, I felt pretty good, though a little colder than I expected given the temp. At one point, I stopped to chat with one of the kayakers, a friend I hadn’t seen in a while, which resulted in my feeling a tad more chilled. So I pushed the pace to warm up some. (Why SHOULDN’T I be able to swim in 64 degrees. I’ve done much colder!) I did manage more distance than I had done in the previous swim–in fact, 2x more distance.
    As the swim drew to a close, I found myself shivering a little (not too much, but I respect shivering as a signal. And my coach recommended that I stop, although part of me wanted to keep going. So I stopped — abundance of caution and all that! — but I was feeling some FOMO. Two other “skins” swimmers, both training for marathon swims, as I have been, lasted about 15 minutes longer. The other two are a lot faster, and even as I was swimming, I was feeling inferior b/c they’d fly past me making me feel embarrassed at my slow pace. As I’m training for Boston Light, I know I have to be good with cold tolerance and speed, and my pool workouts are showing improvement in speed. But will it be enough? I want to focus on the positive, the gains I’ve made, the work I’ve done. I don’t want to let envy get in the way.

    I had a sense of inferiority even before we got in the water, the way they talked with each other, acknowledging me only minimally. Like “we’re better than you.” I’m sure that’s more my over sensitivity than anything they were actually doing.

    So I suppose my decision was wise, but I wish I’d just plowed ahead without telling my coach I was starting to shiver. And I think if the two other women weren’t doing so much better, I might have given myself more grace.